The Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer 2 Hoody claimed the coveted Editors' Choice award for the best overall down jacket. This standout jacket features high versatility and warmth in a lightweight package. At a mere 8.5 ounces, the highly compressible piece can be stuffed into your pack without a second thought. This jacket includes an insulated hood and a hem drawcord to keep in body heat and despite these features still weighs less than nine ounces. With its athletic and form-fitting design, we love it as a stand-alone jacket to ward off cool evening breezes in the summer just as much as we love wearing it underneath an alpine shell while winter climbing or skiing. While it comes with a slightly higher price and its lightweight comes at the loss of a few missed features, this versatile jacket is easily one of the best we have ever worn, and one we highly recommend.Editor's Note: We purchased and retested this award winner, putting it through the stringent side-by-side testing process that sets us apart from others. This review was updated on August 21, 2022, to reflect our current findings.
Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer/2 Review
Compare prices at 2 resellers Pros: Incredibly light, compact, warm for its size and weight, effective hydrophobic down
Cons: No hood cinch, no chest pocket
Manufacturer: Mountain Hardwear
Compare to Similar Products
Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer/2
|Price||$194.99 at Backcountry|
Compare at 2 sellers
$359.00 at Amazon
|Check Price at REI|
Compare at 2 sellers
|$209 List||$119 List|
Check Price at REI
|Pros||Incredibly light, compact, warm for its size and weight, effective hydrophobic down||Lightweight, stylish, high warmth to weight ratio||Stylish, comfortable, long torso provides good coverage||Inexpensive, fully featured adjustability||Lightweight, inexpensive, excellent for layering|
|Cons||No hood cinch, no chest pocket||Expensive, not super durable||Heavy, minimal pockets, down is not hydrophobic||Moderate warmth, noisy material, no internal zip pockets||No hood cinch, no hem cinch, loses feathers|
|Bottom Line||This high scorer offers high versatility, warmth, comfort, accommodation of movement, and light weight||If you are looking for a warm, light layer for a trip where ounces count, this is a great selection||A classic model that does just about everything and does it all well||This down offers the warmth and quality of more premium choices at an approachable price point||A good basic and affordable lightweight down jacket for moderately cold temperatures|
|Rating Categories||Mountain Hardwear G...||Arc'teryx Cerium SL...||Patagonia Down Swea...||MontBell Superior Down||REI Co-op 650 Down...|
|Water Resistance (15%)|
|Specs||Mountain Hardwear G...||Arc'teryx Cerium SL...||Patagonia Down Swea...||MontBell Superior Down||REI Co-op 650 Down...|
|Down Fill||800-fill goose down||850-fill goose down||800-fill goose down||800-fill goose down||650-fill goose down|
|Total Weight||8.5 oz||7.6 oz||14.9 oz||8.7 oz||10.4 oz|
|Baffle Construction||Sewn-through baffles||Sewn-through baffles||Sewn-through baffles||Sewn-through baffles||Sewn-through baffles|
|Main Fabric||10D ripstop nylon||100% nylon||100% ripstop polyester||10D nylon||100% nylon|
|Compression Method||Zips into pocket||Stuff sack||Zips into pocket||Stuff sack||Zips into pocket|
|Pockets||2 zippered hand||2 zippered hand||2 zippered hand, 1 zippered internal chest||2 zippered hands, 1 internal||2 zippered hands, 1 internal|
Our Analysis and Test Results
Built upon the success of the original Ghost Whisperer, this new and improved version made a good jacket better. Made from 100% recycled ripstop nylon that is DWR (durable water repellent) treated and stuffed with ethically sourced 800 fill goose down, just the skeleton of this coat makes it great. By keeping only the necessary features and making the basics work well, this jacket excels with its simplicity. With only two zippered hand pockets and an adjustable waist hem, the Ghost Whisperer works with a simple design for a piece of modern outwear. What's not simple is how well-tailored this jacket is for both movement and layering; combine that with its incredible weight-to-warmth ratio, and you really can't ask for more. While its water resistance is comparable to most of the other downs we looked at, this jacket excels in the dry cold.
The Ghost Whisperer 2 is a surprisingly warm jacket. The amazing weight-to-warmth ratio quickly made this a tester favorite. Whether they were looking for extra warmth for cold belays or gearing up for pre-dawn approaches, our review team quickly latched onto this piece as an essential part of their kit. As a stand-alone piece, this coat works for temperatures down into the upper thirties, especially if you're moving.
If you plan on using it as a belay coat, i.e. standing still for long periods of time or spending much of your day in sub-freezing temps, you will almost certainly want to layer this piece over a fleece midlayer. If temps are getting into or below the single digits, you will want to think about upgrading to a more serious cold-weather option. It performs equally well as part of a layering system or as a super-light single insulation piece. In terms of its warmth-to-weight ratio, you'd be hard-pressed to find anything better.
Constructed using 800 fill-power down, we can honestly say that this jacket demonstrates how the quality of materials matter when it comes to warmth. The Whisperer ripstop nylon does a great job of resisting the wind, a crucial element in keeping out the cold with such a thin jacket. We don't think you will be disappointed.
On our scale, the Ghost Whisperer 2 Hoody weighs a mere 8.5 ounces for a size men's medium; a close competitor, the Arc'teryx Cerium LT Hoody, weighs in at 7.6 ounces. With no drawcord in the hood, no Velcro on the wrists, two handwarmer pockets, ultra-light zippers, and no reinforced areas, the minimalist design of the Ghost Whisperer 2 couldn't get much more pared down. Consequently, Mountain Hardwear relies on some extremely light materials to further reduce the weight of this coat.
Made entirely from recycled materials, the ripstop nylon used on this coat is incredibly strong for an ultralight fabric but can still be susceptible to tearing. Down is the most efficient insulator per gram available, so naturally, it is the material of choice when attempting to make the lightest jacket possible. However, the combination of an ultralight exterior and down insulation can result in some hasty and necessary field repairs if you get bad enough tears. While we have not dealt with any tears in the past couple of years of testing, stories abound on the internet. Be careful and realize that when you opt for going the lightweight route, it comes at the cost of durability. Regardless, for offering such a lightweight and warm down, this jacket received top marks in the weight metric.
The Ghost Whisperer Jacket is similar to this model but without the hood. The main difference is that jacket is a little lighter than the hoody and saves you some money. We prefer a hood in most applications because it adds a lot of warmth and not much extra weight. But the hoodless version is easier to layer under other jackets. We highly recommend both models.
In our testing, we found that the recycled nylon outer fabric, combined with a DWR coating, does a pretty decent job of beading up and shedding water — better than most of the other jackets we tested.
Although we aren't sure whether the chemical composition of the DWR coating has changed in recent years, it seemed to perform better in our testing than it had in the past, and the down is Q-shield hydrophobic down. After subjecting the jacket to our spay test, we found that after a continuous stream of water was applied, the down would eventually soak through and lose much of its warmth-trapping loft. You'll be fine in a passing shower, but as soon as you find yourself in persistent rain, you'll want to throw on a rain shell — as with any piece of down apparel.
When it comes to comfort, the Ghost Whisperer fits much more snuggly and close to the body than most, but in a very good way. Although there was still enough room beneath it for a light layer, this jacket was clearly designed with movement in mind, and there was no hint of extra space or bagginess.
This jacket allowed great mobility in the shoulders, upper back, and chest, and also had sleeves that were plenty long enough, no matter what the arm position. If you intend to wear this jacket while moving, as we did, we think it presents pretty much a perfect fit. This fit made it comfortable to wear and easy to move in.
This jacket belongs on your ultralight climbing or hiking gear wish list. The Ghost Whisperer 2 is highly compressible and packs away into one of its zippered hand pockets, leaving you with a tidy package that's small enough to clip to your harness. It is the smallest compressed hoody in this review, better than both the Arc'teryx Cerium LT, which came with its own stuff sack, and the Patagonia Down Sweater Hoody, that similarly stuffed into its own pocket. This translated to the jacket fitting easily into any small place in our packs and on our harnesses for longer climbs.
The down regains its loft quickly after being compressed and is immensely durable. Throw it in your pack and forget about it until the cold reminds you it's there. It takes up less space than any other fully-featured insulated jacket that we've tested.
The Ghost Whisperer 2 is defined more by what it doesn't have than what it does. This piece is a minimalist's dream and will make others redefine what "essential" features really are. The elastic hood rim and cuffs lack adjustability but have no trouble keeping out drafts and keeping in body heat. This provides adequate protection and performance and keeps the grams down. In truly horrid squalls of wind, you might want the adjustability of a cinchable hood like that of the Rab Microlight Alpine, but overall we didn't find ourselves missing this often unutilized feature.
The two handwarmer pockets are placed high enough on the body of the jacket to not get buried under a harness. The hem sits low enough to stay under your harness when you're moving, and the sleeves accommodate a positive ape index when reaching. We wish this jacket had some internal stash pockets, like many of the other warmth layers we tested. Our testers also didn't care for the fact that the hem drawcord leaves a large loop of bungee cord hanging down below the waist for gear or brush to get caught on.
Other than the lack of pockets and the long drawcord, our other biggest complaint is how small the zipper is. This only becomes an issue while wearing bulky gloves, but nothing is more obnoxious than not being able to easily work a zipper when it's cold enough to be wearing gloves in the first place.
The Ghost Whisperer is designed for technical use — think climbing or backcountry skiing. It thrives in moderately cold temperatures where it can spend some of the time in the pack, and where the thickest and warmest of outer layers are not necessary. At the same time, the clean silhouette and athletic fit make this a great piece for cold-weather streetwear.
Due to its thin construction, this is a good option for actually exercising in, rather than just waiting out the cold. It's also a great choice for mountain use in the summer when temperatures can fluctuate drastically, and a lightweight warmth layer can be very handy.
Should You Buy the Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer 2 Hoody?
The Ghost Whisperer 2 Hoody is easily one of the best overall down jackets on the market. It is very light, super packable, and shows surprising warmth and water resistance for such a thin garment. While we think it was one of the best jackets in this review, we warn that it would not be our first choice as a cold-weather belay jacket where there will be lots of standing around, or for consistent single-digit or below zero cold as that found in Alaska or the high Himalaya. It is best used for active pursuits in moderate cold and has the versatility to serve as an outer layer or as a warm mid-layer. This jacket truly embodies the ethos of innovation and lightweight, and we happily recommend it to you, the reader.
What Other Down Jackets Should You Consider?
When you compare price points, you'll notice that the Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer outperforms many that follow it — and at a lower price. While this is our first pick in our line up, other jackets are also worth your consideration. If you're shopping on a budget, the Patagonia Down Sweater and Rab Microlight Alpine are top performers that will save you a little. If you want to save even more, consider our value picks, the Montbell Superior Down or REI Co-op 650 2.0.
— James Lucas & Buck Yedor
Ad-free. Influence-free. Powered by Testing.
GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No cherry-picked units sent by manufacturers. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing and comparison.Learn More